The primary difference between these two men is their standing when they expire. Walter goes out a killer. Keyes knows the whole truth, and chooses to shame Walter rather than get angry. After a lengthy confession, Walter becomes desperate. He claims that if Keyes doesn't stop him that he can cross the border. Rather, Neff doesn't make it to the elevator. He completes his fall from grace with a fall to the ground. It is here that the director is able to fully capture Walter in all of his squalor. Keyes, looking down on him quite literally, a defeated look on his face, even his cigarette looks dirty and damp.
Vincennes, quite the opposite, plans to die a hero. His smirk can be attributed to his plan to alert Exley that Dudley is the man that can kill and get away with it. Despite his dire circumstances, the director is able to frame Vincennes as a hero. His brave eye contact with his murderer and his having the wherewithal to save lives as he's dying make him a hero. His vivacious face is a stark contrast to Neff's lifeless, sweaty, and gray (I know it's a black and white film but still) skin.
While both men are dying of the same cause, the directors have chosen very different ways for them to go out. One in shame, one in valor, these men each died in a different light.


Great choices of images yo compare/contrast, Dylan.
ReplyDeleteHere's a suggestion: say more about the color in the "L.A. Confidential" image. Did you notice the white collar on Jack V.? Is he a "white knight" of sorts?
I like that you made a parallel while making it contrasting. I also think that how you describe that one goes out in a more 'graceful' way as a "hero" though he's been crooked his whole career, while the other, who has been a nice man his whole life goes out as a "criminal" or a "murderer".
ReplyDeleteI really like the contrasts you made here. Also, I like how you mentioned that Neff is on the ground, symbolizing his fall, while Vincennes is sitting in a chair as he dies, framing him as a hero. Did you notice the position of the other character in each of the frames? How are they portrayed?
ReplyDeleteGreat comparison with the two deaths in these movies. I think they are two great shots as they are very similar, but as you analyzed them, they had two different meanings. I feel like your view on Walter is great because he really is portrayed as a desperate and shameful man. While on the other hand, the death of Vincennes looks extremely honorable.
ReplyDelete